Skip to content
Today's learning is dedicated L'iluy Nishmas Mordechai Ben Dan Zev Moshe our beloved brother on his second Yahrzeit. Dedicate Class

TorahAnytimes Newsletter Vayetzei

Nov 21, 2026 • Parshat Vayetzei

Compiled and Edited by Elan Perchik

header image

Rabbi Yosef Viener

Not Yours to Give Up

Rav Yaakov Galinsky once recounted a remarkable encounter that took place between the Chazon Ish and a young man who had survived the horrors of the Holocaust.

The young man had endured unimaginable suffering during the war. He had witnessed atrocities beyond description, lost loved ones, and emerged from the devastation emotionally shattered. Although he had survived physically, something within him had been broken. He had lost his sense of purpose, and perhaps most painfully, his hope. He had succumbed to one of the most debilitating forms of sadness, that of yeiush, utter despair. Nothing would ever change, and there was no point in attempting to rebuild what had been destroyed.

Rav Galinsky, who knew the young man personally, urged him to visit the Chazon Ish. "What could the Chazon Ish possibly tell me?" the young man protested. "I have been through the war and I have seen things that no human being should ever have to see. If you had witnessed what I witnessed, you would understand. Nobody can help me." Nevertheless, after considerable persuasion, he reluctantly agreed to go. When the young man entered, the Chazon Ish welcomed him warmly and invited him to sit down. "Tell me," the Chazon Ish began, "did you ever learn in a yeshiva?" "Yes," the young man replied wistfully. "Once upon a time. But that was another world. It feels like another lifetime. I can hardly remember what life was like back then. But yes, I did learn in yeshiva." The Chazon Ish nodded thoughtfully. "Then perhaps you would appreciate an interesting shailah."

The Chazon Ish began relating the story of a righteous Jewish woman whose husband devoted himself entirely to Torah study. To support their household, she operated a small business. Twice a year, she would travel to a major commercial fair, purchase merchandise at wholesale prices, and return home to sell the goods over the following six months. On one such occasion, she gathered all the money she had earned during the previous six months and traveled to the fair. This money represented her entire working capital, everything she needed to sustain her family and continue her business. But when she arrived at the marketplace, she suddenly discovered that her money was missing. She searched frantically through her belongings, retraced her steps, and looked everywhere she could think of, but the money was nowhere to be found.

The woman was beside herself with anguish. Without that money, she could not purchase merchandise. Without merchandise, she could not operate her business. And without her business, how would she support her family for the next six months? Someone suggested that she approach the local rav and ask him to announce the loss publicly. Perhaps an honest person had found the money and would return it. Although she had little hope of recovering it, she agreed. The rav made an announcement in shul, and for several days the community was informed about the missing money. Then, quite unexpectedly, a religious Jew appeared at the rav's home carrying a bag. "Rabbi," he announced, "I believe I found the money this woman lost."

The rav was overjoyed. It seemed that the woman's prayers had been answered. But the man continued, "Before you tell me what to do, I want to make one thing perfectly clear. I am a religious Jew, and I want to follow the halachah. I have no interest in keeping money that does not rightfully belong to me. But I also once learned in yeshiva, and I remember studying Eilu Metzios, the second chapter of Bava Metzia. As you can see, this bag contains ordinary currency. There are no simanim, no identifying marks, by which the owner could establish that it belongs to her. And I know that when someone loses money without identifying marks, there are circumstances in which the finder is permitted to keep it. I feel terrible for this woman, and I understand that she has lost her livelihood. But I want to know what the halachah actually requires. If I am obligated to return the money, I will gladly return it. But if I am entitled to keep it, I would like to know that as well. Please give me the psak."

The rav considered the question carefully. On the one hand, the money had no identifying marks, and the woman had undoubtedly despaired of recovering it. On the other hand, the circumstances raised a complicated halachic question. Unable to reach a definitive conclusion, he referred the matter to another rav. Eventually, the question reached Rav Yitzchak Elchonon Spector, one of the great halachic authorities of the generation, who ruled that the finder was obligated to return the money. Although the woman had experienced yeiush, there was one fundamental problem: the money was not hers to give up on, because what a woman acquires is transferred to the ownership of her husband (see Gittin 77b). The money therefore belonged to her husband, who was sitting and learning Torah in another town. He did not even know that the money had been lost. Consequently, her despair could not establish the halachic status of yeiush with respect to property that did not belong to her. The husband, the actual owner, had never despaired of recovering it, and therefore the money had to be returned.

The Chazon Ish finished relating the story and looked at the young man, who appeared intrigued. "That is a fascinating psak," he acknowledged. "A very interesting halachic question. But Rebbe, forgive me, what does any of this have to do with me? I came here because I survived the Holocaust and my entire world has been destroyed. What does a question about a lost bag of money have to do with my life?" The Chazon Ish looked directly into his eyes and replied, "My dear young man, I understand that you have experienced yeiush. I understand that you have given up on yourself. You believe that your life is over, that your future is hopeless, and that there is nothing left for you to accomplish. But there is something you must understand. Your life does not belong to you."

The Chazon Ish continued, "Your life belongs to the Ribbono Shel Olam. Your body belongs to Him. Everything you have are all gifts that Hashem has entrusted to you. And therefore, just as that woman had no right to despair of recovering money that did not belong to her, you have no right to give up on a life that does not belong to you. You may feel that your life is no longer worth living and you may believe that you have nothing left to offer. But that is not your decision to make. Hashem gave you life for a purpose, and as long as He continues to grant you life, that purpose remains. If you surrender to despair, how will you serve Hashem? How will you marry, build a family, and raise children? How will you fulfill the mission for which you were placed in this world? You cannot simply abandon those responsibilities because you have concluded that your future is hopeless. It is not yours to give up on."

Those words penetrated the young man's heart. Until that moment, he had viewed despair as his personal prerogative. After everything he had endured, surely he had earned the right to surrender. Surely nobody could demand that he begin again. But the Chazon Ish had introduced an entirely different perspective. Hope was not merely a pleasant feeling to cultivate when circumstances were favorable. Rebuilding his life was not simply an option he could accept or reject according to his emotional state. His life was a responsibility, entrusted to him by Hashem, and he had no right to abandon it. Rav Yaakov Galinsky related that the young man emerged from the Chazon Ish's home a changed person.

What had the Chazon Ish accomplished that others had been unable to achieve? Others had undoubtedly tried to console him. They had encouraged him to look toward the future, reminded him that other survivors had rebuilt their lives, and assured him that better days were still possible. But the young man had an answer for every reassurance. They had not seen what he had seen. They had not experienced what he had experienced. They could not possibly understand the depth of his suffering. The Chazon Ish, however, approached him from an entirely different direction. He did not minimize his pain, dispute the magnitude of his losses, or attempt to convince him that life would necessarily become easy. Instead, he reminded him of something far more fundamental. His life was not his personal possession to discard. It was a Divine trust, and with that trust came a responsibility to persevere.

There is a profound lesson here for every one of us. How often do we surrender to our own limitations? We convince ourselves that we are simply not capable or not strong enough. We become accustomed to our shortcomings until they begin to define us. "I'm just not good at that." "I've always struggled with this." "That's simply the way I am." Slowly, almost imperceptibly, we allow resignation to replace aspiration. Of course, genuine suffering cannot always be overcome through determination alone, and there are circumstances in which a person requires substantial emotional, medical, or psychological support. The Chazon Ish's message was not a denial of suffering, but a reminder that suffering does not diminish the inherent purpose and value of a person's life.

We may not have chosen our circumstances and we may not possess the strength to overcome every obstacle immediately. But we are still responsible for the opportunities that remain within our reach. Our lives have been entrusted to us by the Ribbono Shel Olam and they are not ours to dismiss simply because the road ahead appears difficult. You may have lost your confidence. You may have lost your direction. You may even have lost your hope. But you have not lost your purpose. Because as long as Hashem continues to give you life, there is still something for you to accomplish.

And what Hashem has not given up on, you have no right to give up on either.

Rabbi Nosson Greenberg

Every Heartbeat

In Parshas Vayeitzei, we encounter a remarkable declaration by Leah following the birth of her fourth son. The Torah tells us, "She conceived again and gave birth to a son, and she said, 'This time I will thank Hashem.' Therefore, she called his name Yehudah, and she ceased giving birth" (Bereishis 29:35). Leah names her fourth son Yehudah, a name derived from the Hebrew word hoda'ah, expressing gratitude and thanksgiving to Hashem. However, a closer examination of this Pasuk raises three intriguing questions.

First, what does Leah mean when she declares, "Hapa'am odeh es Hashem—This time I will thank Hashem"? Had she not expressed gratitude to Hashem upon the births of her previous children? When Reuven was born, Leah proclaimed, "Ki ra'ah Hashem b'onyi—For Hashem has seen my affliction" (ibid. v.32). Upon the birth of Shimon, she declared, "Ki shama Hashem ki senuah anochi—For Hashem has heard that I am unloved" (v.33). Clearly, Leah had already acknowledged Hashem's kindness and recognized His involvement in her life. Why, then, does she specifically declare upon the birth of Yehudah, "This time I will thank Hashem," as though she had never expressed gratitude before?

Second, there is an unusual juxtaposition within the Pasuk itself. Immediately after Leah declares her gratitude and names her son Yehudah, the Torah concludes, "Vata'amod miledes—And she ceased giving birth." Why does the Torah place these two developments alongside one another? Is there some connection between Leah's declaration of thanksgiving and the fact that she subsequently stopped bearing children?

Third, in the preceding Pasuk, when Leah gives birth to Levi, she declares, "Atah hapa'am yilaveh ishi eilai—Now, this time, my husband will become attached to me" (v.34). There, Leah introduces the expression hapa'am, "this time," with the word atah, "now." Yet when Yehudah is born, she says simply, "Hapa'am odeh es Hashem," omitting the word atah altogether. What accounts for this subtle difference?

Perhaps we can suggest a beautiful interpretation that addresses all three questions.

The key lies in reconsidering the meaning of one seemingly ordinary word: hapa'am. Ordinarily, we understand hapa'am to mean "this time." Indeed, that is precisely its meaning in the preceding Pasuk (v.34), when Leah declares, "Atah hapa'am—Now, this time." But perhaps in our Pasuk (v.35), the word carries an entirely different connotation.

In Parshas Mikeitz, following Pharaoh's disturbing dreams, the Torah tells us, "Vatipa'em rucho—His spirit was agitated" (ibid. 41:8). Rashi explains the expression vatipa'em as "mekashkeshes b'socho k'pa'amon," that Pharaoh's spirit was knocking or ringing within him like a bell. The Hebrew root pei-ayin-mem can convey the concept of knocking or beating.

Indeed, the rhythmic beating of the human heart is described in Hebrew as pe'imos halev, the heartbeats. With this understanding, we can suggest that Leah's declaration, "Hapa'am odeh es Hashem," was not simply a statement about this particular occasion. Rather, it expressed an entirely new dimension of gratitude. Leah was declaring, "With every beat of my heart, I will thank Hashem." She was not merely thanking Hashem for the birth of another child. She was making a profound commitment to transform gratitude from an occasional response into a constant way of life. Until this moment, Leah had expressed her appreciation when something favorable occurred. Hashem had blessed her with children, and she acknowledged His kindness. Each new birth brought another reason to recognize His goodness.

But now, upon the birth of Yehudah, Leah elevated her gratitude to an entirely different level. She declared that she would no longer reserve her thanksgiving exclusively for moments of blessing and happiness. Rather, she would thank Hashem continuously, with every heartbeat, regardless of the circumstances unfolding around her.

Consider the remarkable symbolism of the human heart. The heart continues beating whether a person is experiencing joy or sorrow, success or disappointment, tranquility or distress. It does not suspend its rhythm when life becomes difficult. On the contrary, during moments of anxiety and emotional strain, the heart often beats even faster. Leah was declaring that her gratitude to Hashem would possess that same unwavering consistency. When life was beautiful, she would thank Hashem. When life was painful, she would thank Hashem. When her hopes were fulfilled, she would thank Hashem. And when events unfolded differently from what she had anticipated, she would continue thanking Him.

This reflects the extraordinary spiritual outlook associated with Nachum Ish Gam Zu, who responded to life's circumstances with the declaration, "Gam zu l'tovah—This too is for the good" (Taanis 21a). It is the recognition that Hashem's goodness is not limited to those moments when we can readily perceive it. Even when His ways remain concealed from our understanding, we continue to acknowledge that everything ultimately comes from Him.

We can now understand why Leah does not introduce her declaration with the word atah, as she did upon the birth of Levi. When hapa'am means "this time," it naturally refers to a particular moment. The word atah, "now," reinforces that temporal meaning. But according to our interpretation, hapa'am in the present Pasuk does not refer to a specific moment in time. It refers to the beating of the heart, an ongoing rhythm that transcends any single occasion. Leah was not saying, "Now, on this particular occasion, I will thank Hashem." She was declaring, "From this moment forward, my gratitude will accompany me always, with every beat of my heart." The omission of atah is therefore entirely appropriate.

With this, we can also appreciate the significance of the Pasuk's concluding words, "And she ceased giving birth." At first glance, the juxtaposition seems puzzling. Leah expresses gratitude for the birth of Yehudah, and immediately afterward, the Torah informs us that she stopped bearing children. But perhaps this is precisely the point. Leah had just declared that her gratitude would no longer depend upon receiving the blessings she desired. She had committed herself to thanking Hashem in every circumstance, whether favorable or unfavorable. And the Torah immediately presents the other side of that commitment. First, "Vateiled ben," she gave birth to a son. That was a moment of joy, an occasion that naturally inspired thanksgiving. But then, "Vata'amod miledes," she ceased giving birth. The blessing she had previously enjoyed was no longer continuing. Would her gratitude cease as well?

Not at all. For Leah had already declared, "Hapa'am odeh es Hashem." Her thanksgiving was no longer contingent upon the birth of another child. It was no longer dependent upon circumstances unfolding according to her wishes. Just as her heart continued beating whether she was giving birth or no longer bearing children, so too would her gratitude continue, regardless of what life brought her way. The Torah's juxtaposition is thus not incidental. It beautifully illustrates the very principle Leah had embraced. She would thank Hashem when she received what she hoped for, and she would continue thanking Him even when she did not.

This is the profound message embedded in the name Yehudah. True gratitude is not merely the ability to recognize Hashem's kindness when life is going well. It is the capacity to maintain our relationship with Him even when life becomes difficult, when our prayers appear unanswered, and when the future seems uncertain. We may not always understand why particular events unfold as they do, and we may experience painful circumstances that defy explanation. But even then, we can cultivate an awareness that our lives remain in Hashem's hands. Leah teaches us that gratitude need not be confined to isolated moments of happiness. It can become the very rhythm of our existence. We grow beyond only thanking Hashem when something good happens to living with such an awareness of His presence that every heartbeat becomes another opportunity to thank Him.

Picture of newsletter
100% free

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter

Timely Torah insights, stories, and anecdotes from your favorite TorahAnytime speakers, delivered straight to your inbox every week.